In my previous post I talked about Eliot's bleak representation of the city in 'The Waste Land', where he portrays a particularly degrading view of the faceless crowds of commuters using the city each day. This anonymity is one of the aspects of city life that is addressed in Joseph Conrad's novel The Secret Agent. Georg Simmel wrote that "the metropolis exacts from man as a discriminating creature a different amount of consciousness than does rural life". In a rural village or community, it is hard to go unnoticed. Rural life relies upon the existence of community ties, which don't exist to the same extent in a city. "The rapid crowding of changing images" (Simmel) in a city means that almost complete anonymity can be achieved. In a crowd, one becomes part of the scenery, and can more easily blend into the background.
The character in The Secret Agent that exploits this potential for anonymity particularly well is that of The Professor. "The perfect anarchist". He uses crowds to blend into the city and travel through life with little chance of being found. As Ossipon realises, when he "looked hurriedly both ways before stepping out into the cross-currents, but the professor was already out of sight". And out of sight he remains for much of the novel, appearing only occasionally to help spread fear.
The crowded city is not only exploited by the anarchists, however. Inspector Heat attempts to use the crowds and their contrast with the Professor's isolation to gain power over the Anarchist. He tries to exploit the fact that there exists "the unattackable stolidity of a great multitude [which] was the haunting fear of his [the Professor's] loneliness". Part of the Professor's threat relies on the fear of individual attack and individual death. When faced by a crowd, his philosophy becomes inherently flawed.
However, does this "unattackable stolidity" really exist? Whilst the Inspector may wish to believe that the existence of the crowds of people in the city causes a sort of immunity against anarchists like the Professor, Christina Britzolakis notes that the city actually "appears intensely vulnerable to actual and symbolic destabilization". In an environment where no one is known, where strangers come and go every day, the safety of a crowd is cancelled out by the danger of a lack of community. The safety of a community gives way to anonymity, and allows for a less personal, harsher, more numbing attack. The anarchists know that "[t]he whole civilized world has heard of Greenwich". Not only that, but hundreds of people pass through it every day. An anarchist's goal? To create chaos. And chaos can only be caused where there are lots of people. In The Secret Agent the city is used to portray how the safety and anonymity of a crowd can instantly give way to danger caused by the same thing; it is simultaneously the safest and most dangerous place in the world.
Showing posts with label Shock of the New. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Shock of the New. Show all posts
Thursday, 19 May 2011
The Unreal City: Eliot's 'The Waste Land'
Eliot's epic poem The Waste Land was published in 1922, and portrays a particularly bleak (even for Eliot) view of the city, and the crowds of commuters travelling to and from it every day. The city appears lifeless, and desert-like: there is no sign of the cosmopolitan, hustling-and-bustling image of the city we have today. The protagonist of the poem, Tiresias, can be seen as a characterisation of Eliot himself, who once was a bank clerk in London. Robert A. Day, in his essay 'The "City Man" in The Waste Land: The Geography of Reminiscence' (click here for link to article) says that "Tiresias is many things and many men [...] but among them is the Eliot of 1921, or rather his persona - the 'city man'." The poem takes us through a day in the life of one of these commuters, one of these "city men". Day continues to say that "[w]e find that London references occur in the proper order to provide a cinematic representation of a tiny nightmare Odyssey", providing a harshly bleak view of post-WWI London.
The poem's first section, 'The Burial of the Dead', begins this bleakness, stating that "A crowd flowed over London Bridge, so many,/I had not thought death had undone so many". The crowds of faceless, identical commuters make their daily journey over the bridge, heading for their "death". Their existences are lifeless; they are like the walking dead. Day describes this by writing that "[t]he density of such crowds is typical of the urban rush hour; "death" is their fate, a living death in the Hell of the City". A bit depressing, isn't it? But it really does portray the bleakness and, some would say, resentment of the city in the post-war years. Like the character of Frank Wheeler in Richard Yates' Revolutionary Road (1961), Eliot shows resentment and disparagement towards the life of a commuter.
In the third section, 'The Fire Sermon', the description of the Thames reveals that the river contains no pollution or rubbish. But this is far from positive in this case. The lack of "empty bottles", "cigarette ends", "sandwich papers" and other rubbish portrays no sign of summer. There is no "testimony to summer nights" in the river; all joy has left the place, leaving only the bleak, Styx-like river in its place. There is no life around this Thames. The description is framed by the depressing statement that "the nymphs are departed". For those of you who may not know, nymphs are traditionally represented as creatures of nature, usually beautiful young maidens who love to sing and dance. But there is no singing or dancing at the Thames portrayed in The Waste Land.
In the fourth section of the poem, 'Death by Water', the character of Phlebus is "purified of the city's profit and loss" (Day), but only achieves this purification through a) death, and b) water, contrasting dramatically with the dryness of the city, which we see particularly in the last section of the poem, 'What the Thunder said'. There is "no water but only rock" in this city, and even then we are told that actually there is "no rock". Dry, desolate, and lacking all the ideas of a city we have today, London is once again said to be "Unreal", along with the ancient and once incredibly powerful and plentiful cities of Jerusalem, Athens and Alexandria, and the romantic European city of Vienna. All unreal, all overtaken by capitalism, where money controls everything, and there is no joy left.
Perhaps not the happiest thing for a Thursday morning, eh? :-P
The poem's first section, 'The Burial of the Dead', begins this bleakness, stating that "A crowd flowed over London Bridge, so many,/I had not thought death had undone so many". The crowds of faceless, identical commuters make their daily journey over the bridge, heading for their "death". Their existences are lifeless; they are like the walking dead. Day describes this by writing that "[t]he density of such crowds is typical of the urban rush hour; "death" is their fate, a living death in the Hell of the City". A bit depressing, isn't it? But it really does portray the bleakness and, some would say, resentment of the city in the post-war years. Like the character of Frank Wheeler in Richard Yates' Revolutionary Road (1961), Eliot shows resentment and disparagement towards the life of a commuter.
In the third section, 'The Fire Sermon', the description of the Thames reveals that the river contains no pollution or rubbish. But this is far from positive in this case. The lack of "empty bottles", "cigarette ends", "sandwich papers" and other rubbish portrays no sign of summer. There is no "testimony to summer nights" in the river; all joy has left the place, leaving only the bleak, Styx-like river in its place. There is no life around this Thames. The description is framed by the depressing statement that "the nymphs are departed". For those of you who may not know, nymphs are traditionally represented as creatures of nature, usually beautiful young maidens who love to sing and dance. But there is no singing or dancing at the Thames portrayed in The Waste Land.
In the fourth section of the poem, 'Death by Water', the character of Phlebus is "purified of the city's profit and loss" (Day), but only achieves this purification through a) death, and b) water, contrasting dramatically with the dryness of the city, which we see particularly in the last section of the poem, 'What the Thunder said'. There is "no water but only rock" in this city, and even then we are told that actually there is "no rock". Dry, desolate, and lacking all the ideas of a city we have today, London is once again said to be "Unreal", along with the ancient and once incredibly powerful and plentiful cities of Jerusalem, Athens and Alexandria, and the romantic European city of Vienna. All unreal, all overtaken by capitalism, where money controls everything, and there is no joy left.
Perhaps not the happiest thing for a Thursday morning, eh? :-P
Wednesday, 18 May 2011
War in the 20th Century: Thomas Hardy and Virginia Woolf
1900-1953. The period of time covered by the second of my two 2nd-year English modules, entitled "Shock of the New". A time covering just over half of the 20th Century, incorporating some of the world's most important developments. Aircraft, cars, music, modern art, you name it. It's also a period incorporating some of the most important and most destructive wars the world has known. So it's no surprise that war is one of the main themes in much of the literature of the time. The early twentieth-century saw the rise of the war poet, with people desperate to learn what it was actually like in the battle-fields. Two of the most interesting writers of this period, in my opinion, with regards to war, are Thomas Hardy and Virginia Woolf.
Thomas Hardy's poetry is littered with references to the wars he saw in his lifetime. Namely, the Boer War and, of course, World War I. However, as Samuel Hynes notes, "when critics write about modern war poetry, they rarely mention Thomas Hardy" ('Hardy and the Battle God', in Thomas Hardy Reappraised: Essays in honour of Michael Millgate. ed. K. Wilson. Toronto: UTP. 2006. pp.245-261). But why is this? Why, when Hardy lived through two of the most important wars (for Britain) in the 20th Century and wrote many poems about them, is he not regarded among critics as a war poet? Samuel Hynes goes on to clarify: "In our time [...] we take 'war poet' to mean a poet who was a soldier first, who learned about war by fighting before he wrote about it." You know the types, Rupert Brooke, Siegfried Sassoon, Wilfred Owen. The guys who really experienced war as it happened. Hardy never saw a war, only heard reports of them. But why should that mean that his poems carry any less weighting? For me personally, when I hear "war poem", one of the first poems that springs to mind is Hardy's 'Drummer Hodge', not least for its poignancy and relevance to not just the Boer War, but all wars. Hodge, one of the youngest soldiers in the war, as a drummer, is carelessly "thrown" into his war grave "just as found", not given a dignified funeral, but simply a part of the process of war. He is now destined to remain forever on foreign soil, away from home, underneath "foreign constellations". I first came across this poem as a schoolchild, and it has honestly stayed with me ever since. And Hardy's other war poetry is no less poignant. Hardy was harshly critical of modern war: how war had evolved from the romantic tales of his youth. He said himself in a letter that "I constantly deplore the fact that 'civilized' nations have not learnt some more excellet and apostolic way of settling disputes than the old and barbarous one...". In his poem 'The Sick Battle-God', Hardy begins with remembering the romantic times wen "men found joy in war", a time when war involved majestic kings and "storied hero[es]". This romantic ideal is broken with the "modern meditation" that "broke/His [the god's] spell". The tone of the poem changes from romantic and idealistic to harsh and despondent, the final stanze portraying the melancholy truth of modern warfare:
Similarly, Virginia Woolf's Mrs Dalloway does not explicitly portray war. The impact of war, and notably the First World War, stretched far beyond its end date in 1918. Soldiers came back traumatised, with severe mental health problems that would not be fully understood by psychotherapists for getting on for half a century. Mrs Dalloway is one of the texts that really makes it possible, in my opinion, to understand, even just a little bit, the pain that returning home from the war could cause. Karen DeMeester, is seems, holds a similar view (here for link to article): "[Woolf's] modernist narrative form brilliantly mirrors the mind of a trauma survivor like Septimus". She goes on to explain a little about the effects of post-war trauma:
Virgina Woolf does not explicitly deal with the theme of war in her novel. She does not, except on a few occasions, mention the fighting, the impact on the world at home, how terrible it had all been. But in including Septimus in her "stream-of-consciousness" novel, she gives light to a whole new side to the tragedy of war. Like Hardy, who could not talk about war from personal fighting experience, "the customary trappings of war are all missing" (Hynes) from Woolf's novel, too. But this, if anything, provides a more poignant and more relatable experience of one of the most horrific events of the 20th Century.
Thomas Hardy's poetry is littered with references to the wars he saw in his lifetime. Namely, the Boer War and, of course, World War I. However, as Samuel Hynes notes, "when critics write about modern war poetry, they rarely mention Thomas Hardy" ('Hardy and the Battle God', in Thomas Hardy Reappraised: Essays in honour of Michael Millgate. ed. K. Wilson. Toronto: UTP. 2006. pp.245-261). But why is this? Why, when Hardy lived through two of the most important wars (for Britain) in the 20th Century and wrote many poems about them, is he not regarded among critics as a war poet? Samuel Hynes goes on to clarify: "In our time [...] we take 'war poet' to mean a poet who was a soldier first, who learned about war by fighting before he wrote about it." You know the types, Rupert Brooke, Siegfried Sassoon, Wilfred Owen. The guys who really experienced war as it happened. Hardy never saw a war, only heard reports of them. But why should that mean that his poems carry any less weighting? For me personally, when I hear "war poem", one of the first poems that springs to mind is Hardy's 'Drummer Hodge', not least for its poignancy and relevance to not just the Boer War, but all wars. Hodge, one of the youngest soldiers in the war, as a drummer, is carelessly "thrown" into his war grave "just as found", not given a dignified funeral, but simply a part of the process of war. He is now destined to remain forever on foreign soil, away from home, underneath "foreign constellations". I first came across this poem as a schoolchild, and it has honestly stayed with me ever since. And Hardy's other war poetry is no less poignant. Hardy was harshly critical of modern war: how war had evolved from the romantic tales of his youth. He said himself in a letter that "I constantly deplore the fact that 'civilized' nations have not learnt some more excellet and apostolic way of settling disputes than the old and barbarous one...". In his poem 'The Sick Battle-God', Hardy begins with remembering the romantic times wen "men found joy in war", a time when war involved majestic kings and "storied hero[es]". This romantic ideal is broken with the "modern meditation" that "broke/His [the god's] spell". The tone of the poem changes from romantic and idealistic to harsh and despondent, the final stanze portraying the melancholy truth of modern warfare:
Let men rejoice, let men deplore,Hardy may not have seen war first-hand, he may not have experienced the horror of the trenches or heard the deafening gunfire from 100 yards away, but this does not mean that his war poetry is any less significant for understanding the trauma of war.
The lurid Deity of heretofore
Succumbs to one of saner nod;
The Battle-god is god no more.
Similarly, Virginia Woolf's Mrs Dalloway does not explicitly portray war. The impact of war, and notably the First World War, stretched far beyond its end date in 1918. Soldiers came back traumatised, with severe mental health problems that would not be fully understood by psychotherapists for getting on for half a century. Mrs Dalloway is one of the texts that really makes it possible, in my opinion, to understand, even just a little bit, the pain that returning home from the war could cause. Karen DeMeester, is seems, holds a similar view (here for link to article): "[Woolf's] modernist narrative form brilliantly mirrors the mind of a trauma survivor like Septimus". She goes on to explain a little about the effects of post-war trauma:
"The survivor's traumatised mind apprehends the traumatic event as ever-present, and his memories of the event often exist in the present consciousness"This is certainly evident in Septimus. At the time of the one, haunting trauma that befell him, when his friend Evans was killed, Septimus "congratulated himself upon feeling very little" (p.73). But it is this lack of feeling that continues to haunt him after the war is over. Just a page later it is stated that "he could not feel", and he admits himself that when "his wife was crying [...] he felt nothing" (p.77). Septimus brings back with him not just horrific flashbacks and hallucinations regarding his past ("he saw things, too - he had seen an old woman's head in the middle of a fern"), but a terrifying numbness that neither he, nor anybody else, can explain. Mental health was not yet a recognised medical issue, insofar that doctors could not explain away such symptoms, and so being unable to give meaning to the traumatic events or the daily hauntings Septimus goes through, he eventually drives himself into the panic that leads to his tragic death.
Virgina Woolf does not explicitly deal with the theme of war in her novel. She does not, except on a few occasions, mention the fighting, the impact on the world at home, how terrible it had all been. But in including Septimus in her "stream-of-consciousness" novel, she gives light to a whole new side to the tragedy of war. Like Hardy, who could not talk about war from personal fighting experience, "the customary trappings of war are all missing" (Hynes) from Woolf's novel, too. But this, if anything, provides a more poignant and more relatable experience of one of the most horrific events of the 20th Century.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)