"Disguise is the most common artifice, not merely of comedy, but of the Drama generally" (D.J Snider - click here for link). We're all familiar with it. The use of disguise for dramatic effect. And it is particularly common in Comedy, for various reasons. with disguise, you get confusion, mistaken identities, and with these, you get laughter. On the Elizabethan stage, playwrights frequently included disguise, or deception, in their comedies, using it as a comedic device.
One of the most obvious and memorable examples of disguise used in Early Modern Comedy is that of Twelfth Night. Viola, shipwrecked and grieving, disguises herself as Cesario, a eunuch, in order to become a servant to the Lord Orsino ("Conceal me what I am, and be my aid/For such disguise as haply shall become/The form of my intent", I.ii). This disguise leads to more confusion and more mistaken identities than any other play I have ever seen, studied, or performed. Viola is believed to be a man (Shakespearen transvestite comedy in its purest form), Olivia falls in love with Cesario believing him to be male, Sebastian is mistaken for Cesario (and therefore his sister) and ends up marrying Olivia, Viola is mistaken for Sebastian, and everyone is thoroughly confused until the end of the plot when it is revealed that Sebastian is alive and well and Cesario is actually a girl. Phew.
But this is not the only example of disguise in the play. Olivia's steward, Malvolio, dresses in crossed garters and yellow stockings in the hope of winning the fair Olivia's heart, and Feste, the clown, disguises himself as a priest, Sir Topas, in order to fool Malvolio. This itself is an interesting deception. Although it is dark, meaning that Malvolio will not be able to see him, Feste still dons the costume of a priest, portraying the importance of clothing in identity. Feste uses the costume to concrete his new "identity", playing on the idea that by putting on different clothes, you can change your personal identity. To a varied audience of all classes, this would have been laughable for everyone. The thought that by dressing in a nobleman's clothes, you can become a nobleman? The very idea! Anyway, you see what I mean.
Malvolio's change of dress is not so much a disguise, but it does represent a change of identity. Malvolio dons his new clothes in the hope of appearing as a nobleman, much like Feste dresses differently to impersonate a nobleman. Ultimately, Malvolio's attempts fail (quite drastically), and his attempts to use disguise for personal gain end in his humiliation and failure.
This use of disguise for personal gain is a theme portrayed in similar ways in Jonson's Bartholomew Fair, however disguise is used more subtly than in Twelfth Night. The Fair causes almost every character to assume a false identity, as the vulgarity and Carnivalesque nature of the Fair have bizarre effects on the Londoners. As Katharine Eisaman Maus writes, "[t]he Londoners assume they will experience the fair as tourists, from an emotional distance. But the shabby booths and dusty performance spaces have unexpectedly transformative effects on the visitors." (English Renaissance Drama: A Norton Anthology, ed. D. Bevington. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2002. p.961). The visitors to the fair all experience some form of identity change, using the fair itself as a disguise.
The most interesting disguise in the play is that of Justice Adam Overdo, who adopts a disguise in order to seek out wrong-doings at the fair. This, like Malvolio's disguise in Twelfth Night, ultimately fails, and the Judge gets accused of theft, put in the stocks, and publically humiliated, shown to be as false as everyone else at the Fair. Overdo's disguise begins, as with most other disguises, with the costume ("They may have seen many a fool in the habit of a justice, but never till now a justice in the habit of a fool"), but, rather than this being the ultimate identity-altering factor, it is only when he is treated as a fool that he truly becomes one (what's here? A stoic in the stocks? The fool is turned philosopher"). Here Overdo's disguise is transformed from deceptive disguise to true identity, almost like his first identity as a Judge has diasppeared.
Disguise is used to hilarious effect in both these plays, in slightly different ways. But in both to portray the transient nature of identity: it is possible to transform oneself almost completely by assuming the costume and role of another person. Just, incidentally, as the actors themselves do on the stage.
Showing posts with label Bartholomew Fair. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bartholomew Fair. Show all posts
Monday, 16 May 2011
Monday, 9 May 2011
The Grotesque Body: Falstaff and Ursula
One of the themes that my seminar tutor for my first 2nd-year undergraduate English module, Shakespeare and Renaissance Comedy, was very concerned with was that of The Grotesque Body, a concept first put forward by Mikhail Bakhtin. The concept of the Grotesque Body is closely related to Carnival, and the world of excess associated with it. Bakhtin wrote that:
Sir John Falstaff of Merry Wives is the very same Falstaff as appeared in Henry IV, after Queen Elizabeth I herself allegedly saw the history play and asked for a play about "the fat knight", as he was known. There are various pictures and paintings of Falstaff around, but I think that this one, by Eduard von Grutzner, portrays the character at his most "grotesque":
You see here an example of the kind of thing Bakhtin was talking about. Excessive, seemingly continuous, fat, and generally disgusting, yet still also sexually available and fertile. Think lecherous old man down the local pub who's had a bit too much to drink, and you've pretty much got Falstaff, except not quite as bad.
The name 'Falstaff' could be a 'punny' (forgive me) reference to the character's fertility and supposed sexual prowess, indeed, he frequently makes claims about his 'full staff', claiming that the Mistress Page "examined [his] parts with most judicious oeillades..." (1.3), and talking about "the attraction of [his] good parts" (2.2). Indeed it seems like our dear Mr Falstaff is little obsessed with just how "good" his "parts" are (oo-er). Frequently in the text as well do we see reference to the fat knight's size. Not only did Mistress Page examine his parts, but also his "portly belly", he says of himself that "I am in the waist two yards about" (1.3), and after his rather embarrassing dip in the river he says that "water swells a man, and what a thing should I have been when I had been swelled?" (3.5).
So it is clear that dear old Sir John Falstaff is an example of the physical traits of the grotesque body, but it is also much more than the simple physical descriptions. His predatory sexual nature adds to the grossness of it all, as does his purpose as a 'laughing stock' in the play. In Merry Wives we do not so much laugh with Falstaff, i.e. he does not play the role of a clown or a fool, such as Feste in Twelfth Night, but, rather, we laugh at him. This concept in itself is very much linked to the world of the Carnival and the grotesque. When Falstaff is humiliated, it is not amusing in the traditional sense of comedy, but in the more carnivalesque sense. Take for example this scene from The Hunchback of Notre Dame:
Now, I know that I'm studying a literature degree and all, and that this is from a Disney movie, but this is a perfect representation of the type of humour we see with the grotesque. Slightly different, evidently, in the fact that we feel sympathy for Quasimodo (due to the Disney nature of the film), whereas Falstaff doesn't have the redeeming quality of being loveable and wonderfully nice. But at the end of the play, I think it is fairly easy to feel some sort of compassion for Falstaff, and this is evident in the other characters welcoming him back into the community, and not just casting him away. This is where the comedy changes. We are no longer laughing at Falstaff, and so his grotesque qualities actually start to diminish. But that's another story.
The other most grotesque character I studied on this module has to be the character of Ursula from Bartholomew Fair. Different from Falstaff, in the evident fact that she is a woman. However, it has been suggested that Jonson took his initial inspiration for the character from a description of Falstaff in Henry IV, where he is referred to as a "roasted Manningtree Ox with the pudding in his belly" and a "Bartholomew boar-pig". Now, if there is any character to encapsulate these two descriptions better than the "fatness of the fair" herself, I don't know how they would do it. She is, for me, the epitome of what the grotesque body represents.
Neil Rhodes, in his essay 'The Fatness of the Fair', writes that "Bartholomew Fair is the apotheosis of Elizabethan Grotesque", and also goes on to compare her with, who would have guessed it, Falstaff himself: "[Ursula's] body, like Falstaff's, is composed of volatile organic matter...[and] has fertile properties". I know, sounds like a delightful character, no? Just wait until you see the descriptions given of her in the play itself. In the first act she is described by Busy as "a great face, a foul face...it may be eaten, and in the fair, I take it, in a booth, the tents of the wicked" (1.6). She describes herself as "all fire and fat" (2.2) and as a "plain plump wench...juicy and wholesome" (2.5).
Katharine Eisaman Maus, in her introduction to the play, states that "Ursula...embodies appetite", and describes her as "gargantuan, sweaty, lowborn, foulmouthed, domineering, promiscuous, and uninhibited by anything resembling principle". She is never fulfilled, and is the perfect example of the Bakhtinian 'neverending' body:
Both these characters portray the Bakhtinian grotesque body to incredible effect in their respective plays. Used for comic effect, and also to portray the excessive and temptation-filled world of Carnival, these two characters are, to be honest, disgustingly awesome. It's no wonder that the Queen herself wanted to see more of the grotesque :-P
The grotesque body is not separated from the rest of the world. It is not a closed, complete unit; it is unfinished, outgrows itself, transgresses its own limits. The stress is laid on thoe parts of the body that are open to the outside world, that is, the parts through which the world enters the body or emerges from it [...] This means that the emphasis is on the apertures or convexities [...] the open mouth, the genital organs, the breasts, the phallus, the potbelly, the nose...I know, lovely, right? Bakhtin refers to the grotesque body as "the ever unfinished, ever creating body". In short, it's pretty nasty. But there is no shortage of grotesque bodies in Renaissance drama, particularly comedies, two of the best, in my opinion, being those of Falstaff, from The Merry Wives of Windsor, and Ursula, from Jonson's Bartholomew Fair.
Sir John Falstaff of Merry Wives is the very same Falstaff as appeared in Henry IV, after Queen Elizabeth I herself allegedly saw the history play and asked for a play about "the fat knight", as he was known. There are various pictures and paintings of Falstaff around, but I think that this one, by Eduard von Grutzner, portrays the character at his most "grotesque":
![]() | |
| Eduard Grützner - 'Falstaff' |
The name 'Falstaff' could be a 'punny' (forgive me) reference to the character's fertility and supposed sexual prowess, indeed, he frequently makes claims about his 'full staff', claiming that the Mistress Page "examined [his] parts with most judicious oeillades..." (1.3), and talking about "the attraction of [his] good parts" (2.2). Indeed it seems like our dear Mr Falstaff is little obsessed with just how "good" his "parts" are (oo-er). Frequently in the text as well do we see reference to the fat knight's size. Not only did Mistress Page examine his parts, but also his "portly belly", he says of himself that "I am in the waist two yards about" (1.3), and after his rather embarrassing dip in the river he says that "water swells a man, and what a thing should I have been when I had been swelled?" (3.5).
So it is clear that dear old Sir John Falstaff is an example of the physical traits of the grotesque body, but it is also much more than the simple physical descriptions. His predatory sexual nature adds to the grossness of it all, as does his purpose as a 'laughing stock' in the play. In Merry Wives we do not so much laugh with Falstaff, i.e. he does not play the role of a clown or a fool, such as Feste in Twelfth Night, but, rather, we laugh at him. This concept in itself is very much linked to the world of the Carnival and the grotesque. When Falstaff is humiliated, it is not amusing in the traditional sense of comedy, but in the more carnivalesque sense. Take for example this scene from The Hunchback of Notre Dame:
Now, I know that I'm studying a literature degree and all, and that this is from a Disney movie, but this is a perfect representation of the type of humour we see with the grotesque. Slightly different, evidently, in the fact that we feel sympathy for Quasimodo (due to the Disney nature of the film), whereas Falstaff doesn't have the redeeming quality of being loveable and wonderfully nice. But at the end of the play, I think it is fairly easy to feel some sort of compassion for Falstaff, and this is evident in the other characters welcoming him back into the community, and not just casting him away. This is where the comedy changes. We are no longer laughing at Falstaff, and so his grotesque qualities actually start to diminish. But that's another story.
The other most grotesque character I studied on this module has to be the character of Ursula from Bartholomew Fair. Different from Falstaff, in the evident fact that she is a woman. However, it has been suggested that Jonson took his initial inspiration for the character from a description of Falstaff in Henry IV, where he is referred to as a "roasted Manningtree Ox with the pudding in his belly" and a "Bartholomew boar-pig". Now, if there is any character to encapsulate these two descriptions better than the "fatness of the fair" herself, I don't know how they would do it. She is, for me, the epitome of what the grotesque body represents.
Neil Rhodes, in his essay 'The Fatness of the Fair', writes that "Bartholomew Fair is the apotheosis of Elizabethan Grotesque", and also goes on to compare her with, who would have guessed it, Falstaff himself: "[Ursula's] body, like Falstaff's, is composed of volatile organic matter...[and] has fertile properties". I know, sounds like a delightful character, no? Just wait until you see the descriptions given of her in the play itself. In the first act she is described by Busy as "a great face, a foul face...it may be eaten, and in the fair, I take it, in a booth, the tents of the wicked" (1.6). She describes herself as "all fire and fat" (2.2) and as a "plain plump wench...juicy and wholesome" (2.5).
Katharine Eisaman Maus, in her introduction to the play, states that "Ursula...embodies appetite", and describes her as "gargantuan, sweaty, lowborn, foulmouthed, domineering, promiscuous, and uninhibited by anything resembling principle". She is never fulfilled, and is the perfect example of the Bakhtinian 'neverending' body:
I am afraid I do water the ground in knots, as I go, like a great garden-pot; you may follow me by the S's I make (2.2)Urinating uncontrollably as she walks along, Ursula feeds the ground, whilst taking in all the pleasures and excesses of the Fair; there is a neverending cycle associated with her body and the Fair. And yet despite all her flaws, she is still portrayed as a symbol of fertility, just like Falstaff. She is openly promiscuous, and Overdo describes her booth as "the very womb and bed of enormity, gross as herself." She is, as Maus writes "everything Early Modern Englishmen ordinarily thought they despised". "Thought" being the operative word here. Disgusting, greedy, greasy, insatiable and, let's be honest, just a bit grim, Ursula is everything perceived to be wrong about the Fair and the world of Carnival. And yet people can't get enough. Whilst grotesque, she is also compelling and desired.
Both these characters portray the Bakhtinian grotesque body to incredible effect in their respective plays. Used for comic effect, and also to portray the excessive and temptation-filled world of Carnival, these two characters are, to be honest, disgustingly awesome. It's no wonder that the Queen herself wanted to see more of the grotesque :-P
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
